Seth Gabel

as Mr. Brubaker (1 episode), as Pastor Walter (1 episode)

as Walter Johnston (12 episodes)

as Bartender Droid (voice) (1 episode)

as Liam Glasser (6 episodes)

as Michele Besso (5 episodes), as Guillaume Apollinaire (5 episodes)

as John Rice (1 episode)

as Luke

as Man

as Ryan

as Cotton Mather (36 episodes)

as Himself

as Buddy Rovner (1 episode)

as Roderick Usher

as Lieutenant Danny Sefton

as The Count (3 episodes)

as Jeffrey Dahmer (1 episode)

as Brent

as Advisor

as Jerry's Friend #2

as Kissing Man

as Lincoln Lee (34 episodes)

as Jeremy Darling (23 episodes)

as Michael

as Nikolai Koslov (1 episode)