Amy Gumenick

as Samantha

as Sharon (6 episodes)

as Sarah

as Carrie Cutter / Cupid (7 episodes)

as Gilda Darner (1 episode)

as Natalee Holloway

as Gwendolyn Henley (1 episode)

as Natalee Holloway

as Danielle (1 episode)

as Reagan (2 episodes)

as Lee Anne (1 episode)

as Charlotte (1 episode)

as Gwen Collier (1 episode)

as Emma Song (1 episode)

as Amanda (1 episode)

as Mary Winchester (young) (2 episodes)

as Paige Sayles (1 episode)

as Shannon Hirschbaum (1 episode)

as Becca Wells (1 episode)

as Katrina Cooper (1 episode)

as Heidi Taylor (1 episode)